Whole watermelon keeps best at cool room temperature, not in the fridge. It turns mealy around ripening fruit, loses color and flavor in the cold, and spoils quickly once cut.
Whole melons keep better at cool room temperature than in the fridge
Picking good watermelon: A ripe watermelon sounds hollow when tapped, has a creamy yellow ground spot, and feels heavy for its size.
Does a Krisp help? Whole melons are too big for the drawer. Once cut, wrap it and eat it within a few days.
Why watermelon goes bad
Mealy, mushy flesh
Ethylene gasCook it soon
What you'll seeThe flesh is grainy and soft instead of crisp.
Why it happens
Watermelon makes very little ethylene but reacts badly to it. UC Davis reports that 5 parts per million for a week at 64°F causes an unacceptable loss of firmness and eating quality. Hard knocks do something similar: internal bruising makes the flesh break down early and turn mealy. 1
Is it still OK?
Safe if it smells fresh and sweet. The texture is better blended. Toss it if it smells sour or fizzes.
Prevent it next time
Keep whole watermelon away from apples, bananas, peaches and other ripening fruit
Carry it and set it down gently
Use it up
Blend it into juice, agua fresca or a slushie
Freeze cubes for smoothies
Pale, bland flesh after the fridge
Too coldStill good
What you'll seeSmall pits in the rind, with flesh that has lost some of its color and flavor.
Why it happens
Whole watermelon is damaged by several days below about 45°F. The rind pits, the flesh loses color and flavor, and it decays faster once it comes back to room temperature. 1
Is it still OK?
Still good if it smells fresh. It just won't taste as sweet.
Prevent it next time
Keep whole watermelon on the counter or in a cool room
Chill it for a day before serving rather than for a week
Use it up
Toss it with lime, salt and chili
Blend it into a drink
Cut watermelon turned slimy or sour
Bacterial rotToss it
What you'll seeCut pieces feel slick, look dull and smell sour, or the juice fizzes.
Why it happens
Cut watermelon is wet and exposed, so bacteria and yeasts can grow on it. FDA notes that a knife can carry dirt and bacteria from the rind onto the flesh. 21
Is it still OK?
Toss it. Don't taste cut melon that is slimy, fizzy or smells off.
Prevent it next time
Scrub the rind under running water before you cut it
Wrap cut watermelon tightly and refrigerate it right away
Eat cut watermelon within three to five days
Not sure what you're looking at? Pick the produce and the symptom.
Ethylene is a gas that ripening produce gives off. In a closed crisper drawer it builds up and makes sensitive produce yellow, soften or sprout sooner.
Watermelon gives off almost no ethylene, so it is safe to store next to most other produce.
Watermelon is very sensitive to ethylene. Even a little in a closed drawer speeds up how fast it ages.