Tomatoes are damaged by cold, keep ripening on the counter, and mold quickly once the skin splits. They also give off ethylene that hurts nearby greens.
Store stem-side down on the counter at room temperature
Never refrigerate unripe tomatoes — cold kills flavor and texture
Only refrigerate if very ripe and you need to buy time
Keep away from direct sunlight
Picking good tomatoes: Slightly soft, uniformly colored, and fragrant at the stem end.
Does a Krisp help? Tomatoes keep their flavor best on the counter, out of reach of a Krisp in the drawer. Ripe ones can move to the fridge for a day or two.
Why tomatoes go bad
Mealy, bland tomatoes
Too coldCook it soon
What you'll seeFlesh is soft and grainy, flavor is flat, and color may be blotchy.
Why it happens
Tomatoes are damaged by cold. Below 50°F for more than two weeks, or at 41°F for more than six to eight days, they lose flavor, soften early, ripen unevenly and rot more easily. 1
Is it still OK?
Safe to eat. The texture won't come back, so cook them.
Prevent it next time
Ripen and keep tomatoes on the counter, stem-side down
Move only fully ripe ones to the fridge, and only for a few days
Use it up
Simmer them into sauce or soup
Roast them with olive oil and garlic
Very soft and wrinkly
OverripeningCook it soon
What you'll seeTomatoes feel soft all over and the skin starts to wrinkle.
Why it happens
Tomatoes keep ripening on the counter, driven by their own ethylene, until they go past their best. 1
Is it still OK?
Safe if there's no mold or leaking. Ideal for cooking.
Prevent it next time
Buy a mix of ripe and less-ripe tomatoes
Move fully ripe tomatoes to the fridge for a couple of days if you need more time
Use it up
Blend them into sauce, salsa or gazpacho
Save cores and skins in a freezer stock bag
Moldy, split or leaking
MoldToss it
What you'll seeFuzzy mold, a cracked skin with wet flesh, or a sour smell.
Why it happens
Several molds, including gray mold and black mold, attack tomatoes, often through cracks and damaged skin. 12
Is it still OK?
Toss it. USDA lists tomatoes as soft produce, where mold can spread below the surface.
Prevent it next time
Use split tomatoes the same day
Keep tomatoes in a single layer so they don't crush each other
Not sure what you're looking at? Pick the produce and the symptom.
Ethylene is a gas that ripening produce gives off. In a closed crisper drawer it builds up and makes sensitive produce yellow, soften or sprout sooner.
Tomatoes give off a moderate amount of ethylene as they ripen, enough to speed up sensitive produce in a closed drawer.
Tomatoes are very sensitive to ethylene. Even a little in a closed drawer speeds up how fast they age.