Simply Krisp
Produce Guide
Produce guide

How to store mushrooms, and why they go bad

Mushrooms don't care about ethylene. They fail from moisture, bruising and age, so how you package them matters most.

Where to keep them
Fridge
How long they last
7-10 days (refrigerated)
Best temperature
About 32°F (0°C)
Don't store next to
Nothing in particular

How to store mushrooms

Picking good mushrooms: Firm, dry, and evenly colored. Avoid slimy or darkened mushrooms.

Does a Krisp help? The one head-to-head trial of an ethylene absorber in mushroom packaging found no difference in shelf life.

Why mushrooms go bad

Slimy, sticky surface

Trapped moistureToss it

What you'll seeCaps feel slick or sticky, look darker, and may smell sour or fishy.

Why it happens

Plastic traps moisture, and wet mushrooms are an easy home for spoilage bacteria. Warm temperatures and long storage make it worse. 1

Is it still OK?

Toss mushrooms that are slimy, sticky or smell sour.

Prevent it next time
  • Store them in a paper bag, not plastic
  • Keep them dry, and clean them with a damp cloth just before cooking

Brown spots or darkening

BruisingStill good

What you'll seeCaps get brown patches or darken overall, but they're still dry and firm.

Why it happens

Mushrooms bruise easily, and handling makes them brown. UC Davis notes that most mushroom losses come from bruising, rough handling and age, not disease. 1

Is it still OK?

Still good if they're dry and smell normal. Cook them.

Prevent it next time
  • Handle them gently and don't stack heavy things on top
Use it up
  • Chop them fine into duxelles for toast, eggs or pasta

Caps opening, gills showing

AgeCook it soon

What you'll seeThe edge of the cap pulls away from the stem and the dark gills show.

Why it happens

Mushrooms keep growing after harvest, so the caps open and the veil breaks over time. 1

Is it still OK?

Safe to eat, with a stronger flavor. Cook them soon.

Prevent it next time
  • Use them within about a week
Use it up
  • Use them in soup, gravy or a mushroom sauce

Dry, wrinkled mushrooms

Drying outCook it soon

What you'll seeMushrooms shrink, wrinkle and feel leathery.

Why it happens

Mushrooms are mostly water. Left uncovered or in a paper bag for too long, they dry out. 1

Is it still OK?

Safe if there's no slime or mold. They work well cooked.

Prevent it next time
  • Fold the paper bag closed
  • Use them within about a week
Use it up
  • Slice them into soups and sauces
  • Dry them the rest of the way in a low oven and grind them into mushroom powder

Not sure what you're looking at? Pick the produce and the symptom.

What went wrong?

Mushrooms and ethylene

Ethylene is a gas that ripening produce gives off. In a closed crisper drawer it builds up and makes sensitive produce yellow, soften or sprout sooner.

The part people throw away

About 3% of mushrooms by weight is usually trimmed off as stems and trimmings (USDA FoodData Central). Some of it can still be used:

How-to guides

Sources

  1. Mushroom: Produce Facts, UC Davis Postharvest Research and Extension Center